California Labor Commission Rules Uber Driver Is An Employee, Not A Contractor

June 19th, 2015

San Francisco, CA JUNE 18, 2015 4:58 PM

Yesterday, NPR, in a news breaking story, reported that the California Labor Commission in San Francisco has ruled that an Uber driver in California is an employee of the company, and is owed certain benefits.

In a decision that could have major implications for the entire sharing economy, the California Labor Commission has ruled that a San Francisco Uber driver is a company employee, not a contractor. In that decision, the commission awarded Uber driver Barbara Ann Berwick $4,152.20 in employee expenses, including mileage reimbursements, toll charges and interest.

The ruling was made public when Uber filed an appeal Tuesday in a state court in San Francisco. Barbara Ortutay, AP Technology Writer says Uber claims the ruling is nonbinding, and only applies to one driver.

Uber says that classifying drivers as contractors is part of giving them the freedom they want. “It’s important to remember that the No. 1 reason drivers choose to use Uber is because they have complete flexibility and control,” spokeswoman Jessica Santillo said. “The majority of them can and do choose to earn their living from multiple sources, including other ride-sharing companies.”

But Shannon Liss-Riordan, a lawyer working on a class-action suit of drivers against Uber, told NPR that the company owes its drivers more than it’s currently giving them. “Uber’s obviously been wildly successful because it developed a concept that caught on,” Liss-Riordan said. “But that gives it no excuse to ignore labor laws that have been put into place over decades that protect workers’ rights. Uber is a $50 billion company, it says. And the idea that it somehow can’t afford to pay for what employers are required to pay for is just a little bit beyond belief.”

In Berwick’s case, Uber argued that it is just a “technological platform” for private vehicle drivers to facilitate private transactions, that drivers are independent contractors, that Uber has no control over the hours drivers work, and that the company does not have to reimburse drivers for any “expenses related to operating their personal vehicles.”

But the labor commission disagreed and found that Berwick is in fact an employee of Uber. Relying on precedent that applied to cabdrivers and pizza delivery employees, the commission ordered Uber to reimburse Berwick for 6,468 miles she drove while working as an Uber driver, at a rate of $0.56 per mile. Berwick was also awarded toll charges of $256.00, and $274.12 in interest.

Berwick also asked for wages for 470.7 hours she worked as an Uber driver, but she was not awarded that payment, in part because she failed to provide some payment documentation the court asked for.

Rulings like that of the commission could mean higher prices for future Uber passengers. It sets up companies like Uber to be responsible for things like Social Security, health care and other benefits. The Los Angeles Times reports that just in California, if Uber drivers were classified as employees, they’d have to be reimbursed for gas, tolls, insurance, unemployment benefits, workers’ compensation and Social Security.

This could mean financial ruin for Uber and its investers.

“Gathering information on businesses before investing in them is an critical step in today’s business world”, says John A. DeMarr, P.I., a licensed California private investigator since 1985, and president of John A. DeMarr Private Investigators.

“Our 30 years of experience makes all the difference – in the service levels and innovative approaches we can offer our clients.”

As explained on his website, John A. DeMarr’s business background check services can help you make better business decisions about selecting new suppliers, customers or business partners by searching several databases exclusively available to the investigative community. If you are considering a business relationship, you need to know about the company’s background.

John A. DeMarr, a well-known Private Investigator in Huntington Beach, has provided consistently innovative process service and private investigation services over thirty years; His firm’s services are reasonably priced, and always within the bounds of applicable law.
To learn more: Toll free 877-493-3463.